Do you toast your pb&j?

39 comments

1. No

2. I do not. I want a soft, gooey mess in my pb&j.

3. I have and it’s pretty delicious. It brings a whole new thing to it, especially with good peanut butter (teddies or store fresh ground).

4. I used to toast 3 slices of bread, then peanut butter and jelly, then peanut butter and jelly for a double decker with melted peanut butter. My kids loved those on a Saturday morning. Indiana

5. Sometimes yes but mostly no.

   I normally toast the bread or Eggo Waffle first and then I spread PB

6. I eat PB&J *on* toast. I think I grilled (pan fried) a PB&J once and it was pretty good.

7. I haven’t ate it since I was a child but I do recall a few times my mother made me a PB sandwich (I was not a fan of the J) pan fried with butter and cinnamon and it slapped hard.

8. Sometimes

9. I do, lol is this something that’s regional? Seems more like a personal preference. I usually toast mine because I make my own bread and freeze it.

10. Not usually, but its definitely in the rotation. Sometimes I want a little crunch and toast with it.

11. No.

12. No

13. I haven’t had one in more than 30 years, but I don’t remember the ones I had as a kid ever being toasted. NorCal.

14. PB and Fluff on toast in 10x better

15. [No](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g9A6ctjHAxE)

16. Not usually, but I have. If you butter and fry it like a grilled cheese it’s messy, but really good.

17. Absolutely not.

18. No

19. Sometimes I “grill” it like you would a grilled cheese in a buttered skillet.

20. Yes, and NY.

21. A horrifying prospect frankly

22. No, but I’ll toast bread and spread butter, then jelly on toast. PB&J I’d rather have on soft bread.

23. Yes. I also make them open face. New York originally now NJ.

24. No.

25. Depends on how fresh the bread is. If it’s a few days old, I do. Otherwise, no.

26. Missouri

    Sometimes, yes!

27. Sometimes. I like it cause the peanut butter gets all gooey and not as thick.

28. No, BUT, a toasted pb & marshmallow fluff? Hell yeah!

29. Toast the bread. Then add the PB&J.

30. Assuming you mean toasting the bread (toasting the complete sandwich would be weird) then yes, I like it just barely toasted to make it a bit less mushy.

31. Hell no.

32. Sure I do, cheers! 🍻

33. Blasphemy!

34. No

35. No

36. No.

    I sometimes make it on toast. But I do not toast the sandwich as that makes the peanut butter and jelly melt and makes an absolute mess on the griddle.

37. No. Never even thought people would do that….

38. Calm down, Satan. Of course not.

39. Grilled like grilled cheese. Its the best. Peanutbutter all melty.