Fellow American’s, In-N-Out or Whataburger?

35 comments

1. I prefer Whataburger but there is not objectively correct answer to this one.

2. Milo’s.

3. Shake Shack

4. Whataburger

5. I’ve never been to In-N-Out so What-a-burger for me

6. In-N-Out was the most disappointing meal I’ve ever had, but only because my expectations were very high as everyone hyped it up. I’m from the east coast and had it in Utah and California. It’s good but not THAT good.

   Whataburger is your average fast food burger.

   Five Guys is way better than both.

7. Culver’s.

8. I don’t know. Neither restaurant is where I live.

9. 5 Guys

10. Easy, 5 guys.

11. In N Out is simple but good. It’s not the holy grail.

12. Five Guys

13. Whataburger but I like both

14. In-n-Out all day, hands down

15. I have heard both these names but am unfamiliar with each.

16. Whataburger every time. Why Bacon…..

17. Whata and it isn’t even close. In-N-Out is lower quality than Braums on my burger scale

18. Neither are offered in my area. I prefer the local diner.

19. Depends on where you live. I’ve never had a Whataburger. I live in walking distance of an In-N-Out. Which do you think I would prefer?

    Personally, while I enjoy In-N-Out (certainly more than Shake Shack, McDonald’s, Burger King and other chains), between the two I would probably choose a Fatburger over it. And while they’re inferior, I would also occasionally consider a Del Taco Bacon Double Del (IMO better than their tacos), or even a Wendy’s single/double.

20. In and Out is more consistent. You can count on it no matter where you get it.

    What-A-Burger is better at a good or decent one.

    Inconsistency is an issue. Every Texan knows that one What-A-Burger you don’t go to, cuz it sucks. Plus, everyone I’ve heard who has gone to one outside of Texas says they suck ass.

    I’m still going with What-A-Burger The closest one to me beats the closest In and Out.

21. Is this some reference I’m too east coast to understand?

22. In-N-Out is better food imo, but I’m visiting TX and Whataburger isn’t bad at all. It’s just not even remotely the same flavor profiles, like In-N-Out always tastes specifically like In-N-Out, so if that’s your preference that’s what you’re gonna choose. Whataburger tastes like a lot of places.

23. I prefer Whata

24. Culvers

25. Neither hold a flame to a midnight burger in a drive-through town on the side of the road in a Denny’s with the waitress also being your cook, calling you sugar the whole time

26. Whataburger and here’s why. Both burgers are fine in their own rights. But in and out has never been there for me at 3am when I’m shithouse drunk and want the unspeakably amazing honey butter chicken biscuit, jalapeño cheddar sausage biscuit or deep throat a bacon taquito like they’re going out of style

27. In n out prices are good, nothing beats Culver’s tho

28. Whataburger

29. Whataburger

30. Whataburger

31. Whataburger 100 percent of the time

32. Cries in Midwest (it’s Culver’s followed by Whataburger, anyway).

33. Whataburger is what I’m used to and I prefer it over any other fast food. I tried In and Out and wasn’t impressed. I have friends who regularly visit Ca and their first stop is In and Out so I wonder if it’s better there? Here i just don’t get the hype.

34. Whataburger. Not close.

35. Burger King